The Two Faces of Calcarea Carbonica:

If you’re new to homeopathy, you might find it confusing that the same remedy can help people who look completely different from each other.

But Calcarea carbonica, the oyster shell remedy, shows us something fascinating about how homeopathy actually works.

Kate Howard RSHom

Homeopath and CHE Community Manager

Let me tell you about two patients I want you to imagine. One is overweight, moves slowly, and loves staying home wrapped in blankets. The other is thin and fragile, always cold, and exhausted from trying to keep up with life. They seem like opposites, right? Yet both might need the exact same remedy.

Here’s why.

The Oyster's Secret

Calcarea carbonica comes from the middle layer of an oyster shell.

Think about an oyster; it’s a soft, vulnerable creature living in rough ocean waters. To survive, it builds a hard shell around itself, layer by layer.

That shell is its protection, its security, its home.

But building that shell takes a lot of energy and resources. The oyster isn’t a vigorous, energetic creature. It’s slow and methodical. It can’t swim away from danger or fight back. All it can do is sit there and slowly, patiently build its protective barrier.

This is the core pattern of Calcarea carbonica in people; the need to build protection when you don’t have much inner strength or “fire” to work with.

The Heavier, Sturdier Type

What They Look Like

They tend to be overweight, often significantly. It’s not that they overeat terribly; their bodies just seem to turn everything into stored weight.

Their metabolism runs like a slow-burning fire that never quite gets going.

They’re often pale and may sweat easily, especially on their head at night. Their hands might feel clammy and cold.

Everything about their body says “slow down, conserve energy, build reserves.”

How They Move Through Life

These are your classic “homebodies.” They like routine, predictability, and comfort.

Change makes them anxious because it threatens the stable world they’ve carefully constructed. They’re not lazy; they’re just operating on a different speed than most people.

Ask them to rush, and they’ll get flustered. Push them too hard, and they’ll dig in their heels.

They need time to warm up to new ideas, new people, new situations. Once they’ve established a routine, though, they can keep it going indefinitely.

What They Worry About

Security is everything. They worry about money, even when they have enough. They worry about their home, their job, their health insurance. They might become almost obsessive about having “enough”. Enough savings, enough food in the pantry, enough blankets on the bed.

It’s not greed. It’s a deep-seated fear of being left vulnerable and unprotected.

Their Bodies Tell a Story

They love eggs. If someone craves eggs in various forms, think of Calc carb. They also tend to love sweets and bread, probably because their slow metabolism is desperately seeking easy fuel.

They’re incredibly sensitive to cold and especially to damp cold. They layer on sweaters, always need the heat turned up, and feel absolutely miserable in cold, rainy weather. It’s like the cold goes straight through them to their bones.

The Thinner, More Fragile Type

What They Look Like

They’re thin, sometimes almost frail-looking. But it’s not a healthy thin, it’s more like their bodies can’t quite build substance. They might eat well but stay skinny. Their bones might be weak or their posture poor, like their skeleton can’t quite hold them up properly.

Children in this state might have trouble with teeth development or bone growth. Adults might develop osteoporosis early. It’s like the building materials just aren’t getting where they need to go.

How They Experience Life

Everything is harder for them. They tire quickly, get overwhelmed easily, and often feel like they’re barely keeping their head above water. Where the heavier Calc carb type moves slowly but steadily, these folks run out of steam fast.

They often push themselves too hard, trying to compensate for feeling weak. But it backfires; they end up even more depleted and exhausted. It’s a vicious cycle.

The Cold Goes Deeper

Without the insulation of body mass or strong metabolic heat, these people are extremely cold-sensitive. They’re the ones wearing winter coats in spring. Cold, damp weather makes them feel very vulnerable.

They might spend their whole lives trying to get warm, never quite succeeding.

The Same Worry, Different Reason

They have the same anxiety about security as the heavier type, but for them it’s even more acute because they know they’re vulnerable. They haven’t been able to build adequate protection, and they feel exposed and unsafe in the world.

They worry about whether they can handle their responsibilities, whether they’re strong enough, whether they’ll have enough energy to get through the day.

So Why Are They Both Calcarea Carbonica?

Both types are dealing with the same core problem: they’re trying to create safety and structure without having much inner strength or vitality to work with.

Think back to the oyster. It’s not a vigorous creature. It can’t fight or flee. All it can do is build a shell; slowly, methodically, using whatever resources it can gather.

The heavier Calc carb type has managed to build a shell, but it’s become almost too much; they’re weighed down by it, trapped in it. The thinner type hasn’t been able to build enough shell, so they’re left exposed and vulnerable.

But both share the oyster’s fundamental situation: soft, vulnerable, not very robust, trying to survive in a challenging environment.

What They Have in Common

Despite looking so different, both types share these unmistakable signs:

They Hate Cold and Damp: This is huge. Both types feel worse in cold, wet weather. If someone says they love cold, rainy days and feel energised by them, they’re probably not Calc carb.

They Tire Easily: Whether heavy or thin, they don’t have much stamina. Physical exertion wears them out. They need a lot of recovery time.

They Worry About Security: Both types are anxious about stability; their home, their job, their finances, their health. They need to feel safe and protected.

They Sweat at Night: Often on the head especially, and the sweat may smell sour. This is the body struggling with that calcium metabolism.

They Crave Eggs: This shows up so consistently it’s worth asking about. Also often milk, cheese, and sweets.

They’re Slow to Warm Up: Both physically (they take time to get going in the morning) and mentally (they need time to adjust to new ideas or situations).

What Happens When Someone Takes the Remedy?

When Calc carb is the right remedy (and that’s important, it has to truly match the person’s pattern), changes happen slowly. Remember, this is the oyster shell remedy; nothing happens fast.

Over weeks and months, people often notice:

They feel warmer and less bothered by cold
They have more steady energy
They worry less about security
Their metabolism starts working better
They feel more resilient, less vulnerable

For the heavier type, weight might gradually normalise, not through dieting but because their metabolism starts functioning better. For the thinner type, they might finally start building some substance and strength.

But it’s gentle and gradual, just like the oyster building its shell.

The Bigger Picture

Calcarea carbonica teaches us something important about homeopathy and about being human. We all have our ways of trying to feel safe in an uncertain world. Some of us build walls of body mass or possessions. Some of us stay fragile and exposed, unable to build adequate defenses despite trying.

Neither is better or worse, they’re just different expressions of the same human vulnerability and our attempts to cope with it.

Homeopathy recognises these patterns and offers remedies that address not just the symptoms but the whole struggle underneath. That’s why the same remedy can help people who look completely different on the surface.

How to Recognise a Calc Carb Person

If you’re trying to understand whether you or someone you know might benefit from this remedy, look for these key elements:

The security theme: Does everything revolve around feeling safe and stable?
The cold sensitivity: Is cold, damp weather really tough for them?
The slow, plodding quality: Do they need time and don’t handle rushing well?
The exhaustion from exertion: Do they tire easily and need lots of recovery?
The egg and dairy cravings: Do they love these foods?
The anxiety about stability: Do they worry about maintaining their security?

If most of these fit, regardless of body type, Calc carb might be worth considering.

A Final Thought

The beauty of understanding remedies like Calcarea carbonica is that it helps us see ourselves and others with more compassion. The overweight person who seems lazy might be struggling with a constitutional sluggishness they can’t just “push through.” The thin, anxious person who seems weak might be fighting a daily battle just to maintain basic function.

Both are dealing with the same challenge: trying to build protection and structure when their inner fire burns low. Both are doing their best with what they have. And both can potentially be helped by understanding and addressing that core pattern rather than just judging the surface presentation.

That’s the gift of homeopathy, seeing past appearances to the essential struggle underneath, and offering healing at that deep level.

Disclaimer

The content shared here is intended for informational purposes only and should not be considered a replacement for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment from a qualified and licensed healthcare provider. The views and opinions expressed in this presentation are those of the presenter and do not necessarily represent those of CHE or any affiliated organizations.

Practitioner Course

Fast-track Practitioner (online)

Foundation

Beginners

View all Courses

Postgraduate & CPD

Fees & Finance

Course Dates